Website Contact Forms vs Phone Calls: What Converts Better?
Should you push website forms or phone calls? Here's what the data says.
Website Contact Forms vs Phone Calls
You have a website. It has a contact form. And a phone number.
Which should you emphasize?
The Conversion Data
| Lead Source | Booking Rate |
|---|---|
| Phone call | 40-60% |
| Contact form | 5-15% |
Phone converts 4-8x better than forms.
Why Phone Wins
Immediacy
Phone = instant conversation. Form = waiting for response.
Commitment
Picking up the phone takes effort. Form-fillers are often just browsing.
Two-way
Phone lets you answer questions, overcome objections, build rapport.
Speed to quote
Phone: Quote in 5 minutes. Form: Quote in hours/days.
Why Forms Still Matter
Some people:
- Can't call during work
- Prefer written communication
- Want to reach out at 11pm
Forms capture these leads. Just know they need faster, better follow-up.
Optimizing for Phone
Make number prominent:
- Top of every page
- Clickable (mobile)
- With hours of availability
Call-to-action:
"Call now for same-day service"
Not: "Contact us"
Click-to-call:
One tap on mobile = calling you
Handling Form Leads
Speed is critical:
- Respond within 1 hour
- Call, don't email
- Text if no answer
Form response template:
"Thanks for reaching out! I'll call you in the next 30 minutes to discuss your [issue type]."
Then actually call.
The Best of Both Worlds
Fixly's Role
Fixly answers your phone calls automatically. That means:
- Every call captured
- Instant booking
- Phone becomes a 24/7 conversion machine
Keep the form. But make phone your primary.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I remove my contact form?
No, keep it for people who prefer not to call. But make phone number prominent for better conversions.
Related Articles
The First Company to Answer Usually Wins — Here's Why
In home services, speed beats skill. The contractor who answers first gets the job 78% of the time. Here's the psychology behind it and how to use it.
How Long Customers Wait Before Calling the Next Company
You thought you had time to call back. You didn't. Here's how fast customers move on.
Ready to Stop Missing Calls?
Fixly answers your calls, books jobs into Google Calendar, and sends follow-ups. Free to start. Pay only when it works.